Recasting is one of television’s quietest tricks. A familiar face disappears between seasons, a new one steps in, and the show carries on as if nothing happened.
Sometimes the switch is explained in the script. More often it’s left to the audience to simply accept it. These seven sitcom characters all had two actors in the role, each for reasons that were practical, personal, or unavoidable.
Darrin Stephens, Bewitched

Dick York played Darrin, the mortal husband of a witch, from the show’s debut in 1964 until 1969. His back problems, stemming from an injury on an earlier film set, made working increasingly difficult. Over time they forced him to leave the series.
Dick Sargent took over the part for the final seasons, which ran through 1972. The show didn’t explain the change on screen, so viewers just had to adjust. The swap is still one of the most cited examples of sitcom recasting.
Aunt Viv, The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air

Janet Hubert played Vivian Banks for the first three seasons of the series, which began in 1990. She was the warm but firm matriarch of the household. When she left, the producers brought in a new actress for the role.
Daphne Maxwell Reid played Aunt Viv from the fourth season until the show ended in 1996. The writers handled the change with a joke, and the cast acknowledged the switch with some humor. Fans still debate which version they prefer.
Becky Conner, Roseanne

Lecy Goranson originated the role of Becky, the Conners’ eldest daughter, when the show launched in 1988. She stepped away in 1993 to attend college. Sarah Chalke took over the part, and her version of Becky became a fixture of the middle seasons.
Goranson later returned, and for a stretch the show used both actresses in the role at different times. The producers even joked about the swap in the scripts. Goranson then played Becky again when the series was revived in 2018.
Marilyn Munster, The Munsters

Marilyn was the “normal” niece in a family of monsters, and the joke was that her relatives thought she was the odd one. Beverley Owen played her in the first stretch of episodes in 1964. She left the series early, reportedly wanting a different life away from the grind of weekly television.
Pat Priest replaced her and played Marilyn for the rest of the show’s run. The show kept the character’s look and role intact. Most viewers today remember Priest’s version, simply because she was on screen far longer.
Morty Seinfeld, Seinfeld

Jerry’s father first appeared in the show’s early days, played by Phil Bruns. Bruns appeared as Morty in a small number of episodes during the second season. His take on the character was a little softer than what came later.
Barney Martin took over the role and played Morty through the rest of the series. His gruffer, more bewildered version became the definitive one. Many fans don’t realize anyone else ever played the part.
Chuck Cunningham, Happy Days

Chuck was the eldest Cunningham sibling in the early episodes of Happy Days, which premiered in 1974. Gary Dubin played him in the first season. Randolph Roberts then took over in the second season.
After that, the character quietly vanished from the show. He was never explained away on screen, and the family simply carried on without him. The disappearance became so well known that “Chuck Cunningham syndrome” is now a common nickname for characters who are dropped without comment.
Gladys Kravitz, Bewitched

Gladys Kravitz, the nosy neighbor who was always sure something strange was happening next door, was first played by Alice Pearce. Pearce won an Emmy for the role. She died in 1966 while the series was still in production.
Sandra Gould took over the part for the remainder of the run. Gould played the same wide-eyed, suspicious busybody and kept the running gag alive. The character stayed a core part of the show’s comedy despite the loss.