Most long-running series don’t set out to overstay their welcome. A hit gets renewed, the cast signs new contracts, and the network sees no reason to stop. Eventually the story that justified the show has already been told.
What follows is a gallery of ten series that, by a fair reading of their own histories, ran about three seasons past a natural ending. The calls are subjective, but the facts about how long each show aired are not.
1. How I Met Your Mother

The sitcom ran for nine seasons on CBS, from 2005 to 2014. Its premise was a father telling his kids how he met their mother. That setup put a built-in clock on the story.
The ninth season covered a single wedding weekend, which stretched out what the premise had already promised. Many viewers felt the series had reached its natural peak several seasons before it ended. The finale divided the audience, and the pacing of the last year is a big reason why.
2. The Walking Dead

AMC’s zombie drama premiered in 2010 and ended in 2022 after eleven seasons. It was a ratings giant early on, and it later spawned a whole franchise of spinoffs. Viewership fell sharply in its later years from the highs of the middle seasons.
The final stretch was extended with additional episodes to wrap up its stories. Fans often point to the years after the major war storyline as where momentum faded. The franchise itself carried on with spinoff series.
3. Grey’s Anatomy

The medical drama debuted on ABC in 2005 and has kept going for more than twenty seasons. It became one of the longest-running scripted primetime series in American television history. Few shows have lasted that long.
Longevity brought a lot of cast turnover, with many original leads leaving over the years. Critics have often said the show’s early emotional power was hard to sustain. Still, it remains a durable ratings performer for the network.
4. Dexter

Showtime’s serial killer drama ran eight seasons from 2006 to 2013. Critics and fans generally regard the early seasons, especially the fourth, as its high point. Later years brought a steep drop in reception.
The original finale is widely remembered as a disappointment. The character later returned in the 2021 revival Dexter: New Blood, which tried to offer a more fitting ending. That revival itself acknowledged how unsatisfying the first run’s closing was.
5. Lost

ABC’s mystery drama aired six seasons from 2004 to 2010. Unlike some shows here, it had a planned end date, which was negotiated with the network. It still struggled with pacing during its middle years.
Viewers frequently complained that the story introduced more questions than it could answer. The decision to set a fixed finale gave the writers a clearer path. Even so, the show’s reputation has been debated ever since.
6. Scrubs

The comedy ran for eight seasons, starting on NBC in 2001 and moving to ABC for its final year. Many fans consider the seventh season, the last on NBC, a fitting ending. The eighth season was a different story.
The ninth season, subtitled Med School, was a soft reboot with a mostly new cast. It was widely seen as unnecessary and was not continued. Fans generally still treat the original run as the real show.
7. The Office (US)

NBC’s mockumentary aired nine seasons from 2005 to 2013. Steve Carell left after the seventh season, which many viewers see as the show’s turning point. The remaining two seasons felt like a different series to many fans.
The show has since found a huge second life on streaming. Its early seasons are the ones most often cited as classic. The later years remain far more divisive.
8. Game of Thrones

HBO’s fantasy epic ran eight seasons from 2011 to 2019. For most of its run it was acclaimed, and it became a cultural phenomenon. The last seasons were shorter and faster, and drew heavy criticism.
The issue was not overlong running time so much as a rushed ending. Having outpaced George R. R. Martin’s published novels, the writers worked from an outline instead. Many fans felt that more episodes, not fewer, were needed.
9. Supernatural

The CW series lasted fifteen seasons, from 2005 to 2020. It began with a clear arc written by creator Eric Kripke, who had planned about five seasons. After that, the show kept going well beyond that plan.
Many fans consider the first five seasons the heart of the story. The series built a devoted following that carried it through its long run. It became one of the longest-running American fantasy series ever.
10. Homeland

Showtime’s spy thriller ran eight seasons from 2011 to 2020. The first season won major awards, including the Emmy for outstanding drama series. Quality was widely seen as uneven afterward.
The story shifted settings and plots several times, often with new supporting casts. Critics generally preferred the opening seasons and the final year. The middle stretch is where many viewers say the show lost focus.