A song’s first intended singer isn’t always the one who makes it famous. Pop history is full of tracks that were pitched, passed over, rerouted, and finally landed with someone who turned them into signature moments.
Some of these detours are well documented by the songwriters themselves. Here are four hits that started life with someone else in mind.
Nothing Compares 2 U

Prince wrote this song in the mid 1980s for The Family, a group connected to his Paisley Park circle. It appeared on their 1985 self titled album, and in that form it was a quiet, funky ballad that few listeners noticed. The song sat in relative obscurity for years.
Sinéad O’Connor recorded her version for her 1990 album, I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got. Her stripped, emotional performance helped it reach number one on the US Billboard Hot 100 and in several other countries. For many people, it’s now simply her song, even though Prince wrote it and kept performing it himself.
…Baby One More Time

Swedish songwriter and producer Max Martin wrote this track, and it was first pitched to the group TLC. They turned it down, so the song went to a teenage Britney Spears instead. TLC’s Chilli has spoken publicly about passing on it, and the story is widely reported.
Spears released it in late 1998 as her debut single, and it became a worldwide success. It reached number one on the US Hot 100 in early 1999 and topped charts in many other countries. It also defined the sound of late 1990s teen pop.
Umbrella

Songwriters The-Dream and Christopher “Tricky” Stewart created this track with Britney Spears in mind. Stewart has said in interviews that her team never got back to him in time, so the song was shopped elsewhere. Rihanna’s camp took it, and Jay-Z contributed the opening verse.
Released in 2007, it became the biggest hit of her early career. It spent seven weeks at number one on the US Hot 100 and reached the top in the UK for ten weeks. Details of exactly who else was offered the song vary between accounts, so it’s best to stick with the Spears story that the writers themselves have repeated.
Because the Night

Bruce Springsteen began this song during the sessions for his 1978 album Darkness on the Edge of Town. He couldn’t finish the lyrics and left it unreleased, though a rough version existed. His producer Jimmy Iovine, who was also working with Patti Smith, passed the tape along to her.
Smith wrote new lyrics inspired by a phone call she was waiting on from her future husband, Fred “Sonic” Smith. Her version came out in 1978 and became her biggest commercial hit. It reached the US Top 20 and the UK Top 5, while Springsteen later played it live on his own tours.