Some songs feel so tied to one voice that it’s hard to picture anyone else behind them. The singer owns the performance, the delivery, the memory. Yet the pen often belonged to somebody else entirely.
Songwriting credits tend to hide in liner notes and streaming metadata, so these stories slip past most listeners. Here are five well documented examples of famous songs written by someone other than the artist who made them famous.
I Will Always Love You, Whitney Houston

Whitney Houston’s 1992 version, recorded for The Bodyguard soundtrack, became one of the best selling singles of all time. Dolly Parton wrote the song, though, and first recorded it in 1973. She wrote it as a farewell to her longtime mentor and duet partner Porter Wagoner when she left his show.
Parton’s original reached number one on the country chart in 1974, and she took it back to the top of that chart with a re-recording in 1982. Houston’s arrangement, with its unaccompanied opening, turned it into a global pop event. Parton has often been described as earning enormous royalties from the cover, since she kept her publishing rights.
Respect, Aretha Franklin

Aretha Franklin’s 1967 recording became an anthem of the civil rights and women’s movements. Otis Redding wrote it and released his own version in 1965, and it was a more straightforward plea from a working man to his partner.
Franklin and her sisters reworked the arrangement, adding the spelling out of the title and the “sock it to me” backing vocals. Her version hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100. The song is a good reminder that authorship and interpretation are different things, and both can be transformative.
Nothing Compares 2 U, Sinéad O’Connor

Sinéad O’Connor’s 1990 recording, with its famously stark video, topped charts in many countries. Prince wrote it, and it first appeared in 1985 on an album by The Family, a side project he oversaw.
O’Connor’s version made the song feel deeply personal, and it became the defining moment of her career. Prince later performed the song himself in concert, but it stayed closely associated with her. O’Connor died in 2023, and tributes since then have often returned to this recording.
Hurt, Johnny Cash

Johnny Cash’s 2002 cover of Hurt is often treated as one of the most affecting late career recordings in American music. Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails wrote it, and it appeared on that band’s 1994 album The Downward Spiral.
Cash reshaped it with sparse acoustic instrumentation and a frail, weathered voice. Reznor has said in interviews that hearing it changed how the song felt to him, as though it no longer belonged to him. The accompanying video was released shortly before Cash’s death in 2003.
Girls Just Want to Have Fun, Cyndi Lauper

Cyndi Lauper’s 1983 hit became a defining song of the decade. Robert Hazard wrote and recorded a demo of it in the late 1970s, with lyrics seen from a male point of view.
Lauper and producer Rick Chertoff worked with Hazard’s material and adjusted the lyrics, turning it into a celebration from a woman’s perspective. Hazard is still credited as the songwriter. He died in 2008, and his work on the song continues to earn recognition from fans who know the backstory.