Pop history is full of near misses. A song gets written with one voice in mind, the artist passes or the plan stalls, and someone else walks away with a career-defining hit.
The six songs below all took that detour. Each one landed with a different singer than the one it was first meant for, and the results rewrote the charts.
Hit Me Baby One More Time

Max Martin wrote this song with Rami Yacoub in Stockholm, and it was first offered to TLC. The group reportedly turned it down, and the demo made its way to a teenage Britney Spears instead.
Her version came out in late 1998 and became her debut single. It reached number one in the United States and the United Kingdom, and it set the template for her early career. TLC’s decision is often cited as one of the most expensive passes in pop history.
Where Did Our Love Go

Motown’s songwriting team Holland, Dozier and Holland wrote this one with the Marvelettes in mind. The group didn’t care for it and declined, so the song went to the Supremes, who were still hunting for their breakthrough.
The Supremes recorded it in 1964, and it became their first number one single in the United States. It kicked off a run of five consecutive chart toppers for the trio. A song the Marvelettes didn’t want ended up launching one of the biggest vocal groups of the decade.
Nothing Compares 2 U

Prince wrote this ballad for The Family, a side project he put together in the mid 1980s. The group recorded it for their 1985 album, and it passed with little notice at the time.
Sinéad O’Connor later recorded her own version for her 1990 album. Her stripped, aching performance and a striking music video made it a worldwide hit, and it reached number one in the United States and the United Kingdom. Plenty of listeners still assume it was her song from the start.
Manic Monday

Prince wrote this track under the pseudonym Christopher, and it was initially intended for Apollonia 6. Instead, it ended up with the Bangles, with Susanna Hoffs singing lead.
Released in 1986, it climbed to number two on the Billboard Hot 100. The song that blocked it from the top spot was Prince’s own “Kiss.” It’s a neat footnote that he was effectively competing against himself.
Umbrella

The song was written by Tricky Stewart, The-Dream, Kuk Harrell and Jay-Z. Britney Spears was among the artists it was reportedly pitched to, and her camp didn’t take it up.
Rihanna recorded it, and it arrived in 2007 as the lead single from her album Good Girl Gone Bad. It reached number one in both the United States and the United Kingdom, and it spent a long stretch at the top in each. The song is widely seen as the moment she became a global pop headliner.
It’s Raining Men

Paul Jabara and Paul Shaffer wrote this disco dance floor staple. Jabara reportedly shopped it to several major female stars, with Donna Summer among those who declined.
The Weather Girls, a duo formed by Martha Wash and Izora Armstead, recorded it in 1982. It became their signature song and a lasting favorite in dance clubs, at weddings and in countless movie soundtracks. It remains a rare case where the final singers made a track feel as though it had always been theirs.